@jyn.erso

[realists]

[ gross, talking to people. but needs must. ]

I need someone to let me stab them.

I'll fix it.

Thanks.

Comments

[lifetothefullest]

That's the impression I was getting, though at least that's better than some other reason for the question.

[So there's... That... He supposes.]

[frontierbashir]

I implore you not to take her seriously.

I'm a physician and offered to have her test her powers on patients that get hurt accidentally, since whatever limits to her powers she has, I could either heal them the rest of the way or use traditional medicine to help.

[lifetothefullest]

Don't worry, I'm not going to volunteer. Not super interested in being stabbed; I've heard it's worse than being shot and that's not very fun.

It does seem a lot safer and more ethical to practice in the way you're suggesting, though I'm not sure you'll be able to prevent people from actually volunteering. The best thing you can do might just be to supervise--if possible--if someone does agree to go along with this.

[frontierbashir]

I can't do that. I have a moral obligation to stop it.

The Hippocratic Oath mandates that physicians First Do No Harm.

[lifetothefullest]

Ideally I'd agree with you, and that definitely applies to harming anyone yourself or intervening if someone else is going to cause harm to an unwilling participant, but in a case where the 'victim' is volunteering it gets kind of grey. I mean, outside of a situation like this you could and probably should pull the whole 'preventing someone from causing harm to themselves' thing, but logistically enforcing that in a place like this is not really feasible. Unfortunately.

[Ethically, yes, it's kind of wrong to allow this to happen, but if it's going to happen anyway then pragmatically the most ethical thing might just be not to participate and then step in to help mitigate the damage as much as possible.]

cw: talk of suicide

[frontierbashir]

I'm sorry, but I simply can't do that. It's like saying "allow this suicidal person to off themselves because they want to".

There are far safer ways to do this.

[lifetothefullest]

It's definitely not the same thing, but it doesn't have to be for you to still be morally against it.

I'm sure there are, I've just gotten used to the idea that you're not really going to be able to stop people from taking these kinds of risks, especially in a place like this. So unless you have some idea of how to actually do so, since your objections obviously haven't been listened to, you may have to just help where you can.